Blog Home |  Email Author  |  About this Blog       Welcome to Community Server Sign in | Join

The Hypatian Shore

"Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no substitute for a good blaster at your side." Han Solo

The Friday Fallacy // Straw Man

By MC Pickard
Friday, Jun 27 2008, 06:02 PM

Introduction

The Straw Man fallacy is often committed by creationists in their defense of a literal creation by a supernatural agency when attempting to refute evolution.

This fallacy can be quite effective - if you are not on guard for it, or do not understand or aware of the opponents position.

Defined

Instead of representing the opponents argument accurately, the petitioner rephrases or misrepresents the oppositions argument as to make it easier to defeat. The petitioner then declares victory over this invented argument.

Therefore the allusion of a straw man. They are easy to knock down.

Example

According to his (Charles Darwin) evolution scenario, inanimate substances came together by chance to give rise to the first living cell.
---
"Living things did not come into being through the imaginary processes of evolution."

This example is from the Atlas of Creation by Harun Yahya. A Muslim creationist. Yes, thats right a Muslim creationist.

Like many creationists, Harun Yahya, restates evolution as a theory on the origin of life. Evolution is a theory on the origin of species. Meaning, Darwinian evolution starts after life begins.

Therefore, evolution can not account for abiogenesis. Because Yahya uses a straw man, it allows for an easy victory, despite the fact that it came at the expense of intellectual honesty.

In Conclusion

Straw Man arguments are an intellectually dishonest way of arguing against a position that one wishes to refute. The victory allegedly won is therefore useless.

Arguments and positions should be honestly confronted and then rejoined on the merits of the position, not one imagined.

Comments

No Comments

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.

About MC Pickard

Primary interest is where religion intersects with the state, issues like evolution, creationism, science, and gay marriage. I am passionate about science, reason and believing in as many true thing as possible. I am critical of religion, skeptical of woo in general. My tertiary interests include city and urban development, art, design, weightlifting, and I can not get enough of Brewers or Packers coverage. I've also been an ordained Minister with the ULC since 5/2007.

Posts

Tags

News

</object >


click here to learn more
Add to Technorati Favorites <!--NetworkedBlogs Start--><style type="text/css"><!--.networkedblogs_widget a {text-decoration:none;color:#3B5998;font-weight:normal;}.networkedblogs_widget .networkedblogs_footer a {text-decoration:none;color:#FFFFFF;font-weight:normal;}--></style><script type="text/javascript"><!-- if(typeof(networkedblogs)=="undefined"){networkedblogs = {};networkedblogs.blogId=82183;networkedblogs.shortName="the_hypatian_shore";} --></script><script type="text/javascript" src="http://widget.networkedblogs.com/getwidget?bid=82183"></script><!--NetworkedBlogs End-->

Search the Blogs