You can almost bet that when an organization uses the word "family" or
"pro-family" they are really about hating gay members of our society.
In Chicago, public schools CEO Arne Duncan, has proposed twenty new programs and among them a new school, the Social Justice High School, a place "to address the needs of the underserved
population of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and questioning
youth and their allies."
Why is this school necessary? Because of the increasing bigotry that this
population of students must face. The statics indicate:
- 35% of Illinois students report that sexual orientation is the most common reason students
are bullied or harassed.
- 34% of Illinois students report that gender identity is the most common reason students are bullied or harassed.
- 74% of Illinois students report hearing homophobic remarks such as “*** got” or “dy ke” from other students in school
- 83% of Illinois students report hearing homophobic remarks such
as “that’s so gay”or “you’re so gay” from other students in school
- 48% of Illinois students report that teachers and other school staff rarely intervene when they hear
homophobic language
- Students who identify as lesbian, gay, or bisexual are three times more likely than their non-gay peers to report missing
school because they feel unsafe (33% vs. 11%)
- Students who identify as lesbian, gay, or bisexual are almost two times more likely than their non-gay peers to report being
in a physical fight at school (32% vs. 17%)
- Students identifying as lesbian, gay, or bisexual are nearly twice as likely as their non-gay peers to report suffering
from depression (52% vs. 31%).
- Students identifying as lesbian, gay, or bisexual are almost three times more likely than their non-gay peers to report
attempting suicide (32% vs. 11%)
Of course, this has riled up the religious right. Laurie Higgins, of the Illinois "Family" Institute, argues
"A high school that is dedicated to or centrally focused on
homosexuality necessarily requires that public educators have come to
some prior conclusions about the nature and morality of homosexuality..."
Prior
conclusions? Which are those? That gays, lesbians, and others should be
treated fairly and receive a decent education free from harassment? No, the
conclusion that Higgins wants lawmakers and school officials to make is
one based on the Bible's morality. You know, the same book that not
only condemns eating shell fish and mixing fabrics, but
also advocates for the stoning of homosexuals, adulterers, disobedient children, and for collecting sticks on the sabbath.
Peter LaBarbera of Americans for Truth About Homosexuality (is it possible to be anymore preposterous!), in turn, argues
"The taxpayers -- whether they're Christians, Orthodox Jews, Muslims --
they will be funding [this] pro-homosexual indoctrination school for
so-called 'gay' youth"
LaBarbera
is
making a special plead on religious grounds, as if all Christians,
Jews and
Muslims are monolithic in their beliefs - which they are evidently
not. And many of these Christians, Jews and Muslims have many gay and
lesbian adherents. However, for the sake of argument, let's contended
that these religious
groups are indeed monolithic and this is a matter of taxpayer rights.
If it's simply a matter of a tax-payer rights, then our taxpaying gays
and lesbians - many of whom are religious, citizens should not be in
the business of paying for
"straight-schools" and creating so-called "straight-youth." And let's
expand that. Should white taxpayers be in the business of educating
black students?
Indoctrination is the business of religion and LaBarbera fails to
acknowledge this in his argument that the students who would be attending
this school are already self-identified gay or otherwise. It seems that
LaBarbera believes that Chicago school system is creating a "gay"
factory.
Patently ridiculous.
Apparently, if your a bigot whose surety is alleged to be God's will, no argument in defense of such a worldview is
truculent, or incoherent enough to make you reconsider your bigotry.
Harris and LaBarbera simply want to block any opportunity for gays and
lesbians to achieve any semblance of equality in our society. They
actively demand
that these people be discriminated and blacklisted as unequals and as
second class citizens. I have to wonder why stop at education? Why stop
at marriage? Why stop at life? Why not actively pursue death sentences
for homosexuality?
The Religious Right hates the family in all its splendid diversity. They hate your gay son. They hate your gay daughter. They hate your gay mother or father. They hate
your gay friends and colleagues. And when called on it, they dress it
up in Jesus' love. What a hollow, conditional love that is.
Here's
a thought. If bigots like Harris and LaBarbera would stop encouraging
religious intolerance that breeds the subsequent intolerance against
homosexuality in our society, perhaps schools like the Social Justice
High school would be unnecessary. Instead, they crusade in their full
religious bigotry like they are engaged in some kind of Holy War. (And by their worldview, it is.)
Leaving aside religious intolerance, there are other criticisms of a school like the Social Justice High School. Hantas Farmer, a trans-gendered citizen, argues that
"Have
any of you considered that this is nothing but de facto segregation? I
support you in principle. School should be safe for everyone. But I'm
not sure segregation is the way forward"
In
my opinion, we've already seen a fracturing of the public school system
with voucher programs that may be used for either religious or secular
private schools. New York and Milwaukee already have similar schools.
I do not see the harm with one more school. A school like this will help to educate otherwise intelligent members of our
society to become productive members so they are not as likely to exist off of government welfare in the future.